Tuesday, August 25, 2026

Women's Holy Disobedience: August 23

Year A, Pentecost 13                        Exodus 1:8-2:10                                  

“Now a new king arose over Egypt, who did not know Joseph.”  Some of you will remember that Joseph was young boy who was sold by his cruel brothers into slavery. He ended up in Egypt and interpreted the Pharoh’s dreams so accurately and advantageously, the Pharoh ended up giving him a great deal of power and authority.  Joseph later forgave his brothers, and his whole family settled in Egypt.  Joseph’s father was named Israel and the descendants of his family were who this new king was referring to as the Israelite people.  It’s the first time this group of people is recognized as Israelites.

Notice, the new king is not named.  Apparently the author of Exodus didn’t think his name was important.  Many have hypothesized on who this king was, but the author of Exodus didn’t name him.  What we know is that not only did he not know Joseph, he didn’t care about the story of Joseph, which is part of the reason that instead of working with the people known as Israelites, he decided to oppress them. He was threatened by a community he didn’t understand.  We see that far too often.

As a result he decided that instead of working with them, he would simply oppress them more and more until they lost their will to live.  However, that didn’t work.  The more they were oppressed, the more they multiplied and spread.  Since oppressing the people he feared was not effective, this nameless Pharaoh came up with an even more evil plan.  He asked the midwives of the Hebrew women to kill all the male babies.  The men were more of a threat because they could join Egypt’s enemies and fight.

            It would seem that the Pharaoh should have feared the women more as they were the ones who thwarted his plan. It was the midwives who saved the day--two women named Shiphrah and Puah.  Those might not be names most of you recognize but their names are obviously important. They are named, even when the most powerful man isn’t. 

They defied the Pharaoh. Why? Because they feared God.   We don’t talk a lot about fear of God. It meant something different in this context then how we perceive it now.  It wasn’t necessarily about being afraid of what God might do.  It was about awe, reverence and respect.  We all connect with God in different ways.  When I pray, I think of Jesus, the more human and vulnerable aspect of God. But God is more than that. The God of the Old Testament had some vulnerable moments, but was mostly associated with awe, majesty and power. 

The midwives had a deep reverence for the God who created the heavens and the earth, the creator God. Because they respected this God of creation, they refused to help a corrupt king destroy God’s greatest act of creation—humans.   So when Pharoh called them before him, they simply explained that the Hebrew women just gave birth too quickly. By the time the midwife was called, it was too late.  The baby was already born and whisked away. The hilarious part of this explanation is the Pharoh obviously felt like he couldn’t argue with these women.  I mean…what did he know about childbirth? 

Later, church fathers like Augustine and Gregory the Great debated whether these women were lying.  If they were lying, then they were sinning and they were wrong to do so.   These church fathers went as far as to say that while these women were rewarded by God in this life, they would not be rewarded in the next life. About 1000 years later, Martin Luther (the man who had the courage to take on church corruption) wrote that these midwives were the model for living under the pressure of persecution because they disobeyed unjust orders.  Their lies were justified because they were meant to aid rather than injure.  Martin Luther (the great church reformer) understood more than most the courage it took to defy unjust rulers and why sometimes, it was necessary.

It wasn’t just the midwives that defied the unjust ruler’s orders.  There was also Moses’s mother.  She was rather crafty in how she defied the orders.  After the Pharoh was thwarted by the midwives, he told everyone to throw every Hebrew boy into the river. Moses’ mother carefully placed him in the river in a waterproof basket…in a place where he would likely be found.  

Another woman, the Pharaoh’s own daughter, chose compassion over cruelty when she found the baby boy in the basket.  She knew this was one of the babies who her father demanded be killed.  She defied him and drew him out of the river and raised him as her own.  At some point the Pharoh must have realized that this baby was one that he commanded be killed, but it would appear that even he could not tell his own daughter to kill a baby. It’s so much harder to oppress and kill when we don’t know the people who we are oppressing. 

What is interesting is that we hear no more of the Pharoh’s plan to kill the Hebrew boys.  For all we know, he gave up the plan because of the courage of the midwives, the sacrifice of a mother and the compassion of a daughter.  They all defied power in a different way and it changed history.  This is not to say that the Pharaoh was defeated in that moment.  He wasn’t. He continued to enslave the Hebrew people.  But he didn’t’ succeed in killing a whole generation of Hebrew boys.  Moses lived and went on to defy Pharaoh in a public and dramatic way.  He freed the Hebrew people. That would only be decades later.  As we know, change takes time.  Civil disobedience can be a very effective tool, but it’s not always the most efficient tool.

What we see from this reading is that practice of civil disobedience has Biblical precedence that goes back thousands of years, long before Jesus was killed by the Roman government, long before the Civil Rights movement.  There are political leaders today who eagerly quote Romans 13 which says, “Let every person be subject to the governing authorities; for there is no authority except from God, and those authorities that exist have been instituted by God. Therefore whoever resists authority resists what God has appointed...”  Current political leaders like to use this line to show that loyalty to the government is our Christian duty. 

The thing we have to remember is that Paul was writing to a community in Rome…people living in one of the most powerful empires of all time.  He was mindful of what could happen when a faith community appeared to oppose the government itself and he discouraged that kind of wholesale opposition.  Yet we can see from our reading in Romans today, which is the chapter right before Paul encourages people to be subject to the governing authorities, he tells people, “not to be conformed to this world.”  That is the tricky position we are in as Christians.  We have to exist in this world and be responsible citizens, but we also can’t be conformed to the world. That means that like the midwives and the Pharaoh’s daughter we must try to discern not just what we think is best, but discern the will of a loving and compassionate God.

You might note that in this entire reading from Exodus, the only time that God directly intervenes is to reward the midwives who refused to follow Pharaoh’s orders.  That would appear to be very limited involvement.  Sometimes we are tempted to look around and observe whatever injustice might be currently plaguing our nation or world and wonder, where is God in this? When is God going to step in and fix this mess? In those moments, we would be wise to remember, that God works through us, the people of God.  God will inspire us, support us, maybe even reward us, but it’s up to us to do the work that requires compassion, love and sometimes a degree of disobedience.



No comments:

Post a Comment